The conflict over commercialism and historic preservation and restoration at Gettysburg reached new heights this past week when it was discovered that the old Visitor’s Center may have been built atop the ruins of the legendary shoe factory, whose existence has been oft-disputed. As workmen smashed apart the buildings that once housed the museum’s collections and the fabled Electric Map, they found evidence of piles of shoes, which upon inspection were determined not to be property of generations of Gettysburg guides or confused schoolchildren. “This discovery will bring new attention to the Ziegler’s Grove area,” park superintendent John Latschar announced. “It vindicates my decision to rip apart the new to uncover the old.”
Yet at the same time, Latschar declared that in light of a recent court ruling that stayed the NPS’s efforts to demolish the old Cyclorama building (which had also once served as park headquarters), he was ready to implement a new plan that utilized the structure in new and innovative ways. Christened “The Schimmelfenning Center,” the building will house several fast foot restaurants featuring funnel cakes and fudge, a sit-down BBQ place called “The General’s Pig Sty,” and souvenir shops that will sell the latest in Civil War t-shirts and baseball caps bearing the likeness of Joshua Chamberlain and Nathan Bedford Forrest. “We know Forrest didn’t fight here,” park spokesperson Katie Lawhon remarked, “but there seems to be money in selling his likeness to a certain clientele, and money is money. Just ask anyone who sells Chamberlain stuff.” Plans call for the installation of a James Longstreet rest station, the construction of a coin-operated monument to Daniel Sickles, and the G. K. Warren “observation point,” which Latschar was careful not to call a tower. To quiet controversy that accompanied recent developments in the park, the NPS will open a really big bookstore, consisting of four shelves of NPS publications and two dozen computer terminals hardwired to amazon.com.
Best of all, the restored center will place the Electric Map in the space that formerly housed the famed Cyclorama, with a new sound system, skyboxes, and an entrance fee of $10. “This allows us to reduce our entrance fee to the Cyclorama and the new Visitor’s Center to $5,” Latscher noted, adding that “given the demand to keep the Electric Map going, we thought we might as well give people what they want, and I’m sure they will be willing to pay the price to keep those memories alive.” No word yet on whether Charlie Weaver will be brought back to life to offer a prologue: a plaque in a dark corner will remind visitors that George G. Meade, not Grant or Chamberlain, commanded the Army of the Potomac. “We’ve worked to balance historical accuracy with popular appeal,” Lawhon observed, adding, “I think we’ve done a pretty good job of it.”
Local businessmen wasted no time in voicing their displeasure. “This is another attempt by the NPS to impoverish us,” one muttered, although he grew silent when someone asked why there were parking meters all over the place if free parking was so important. “How dare they trivialize the heroes of the past!” declared a frequent patron of General Pickett’s Buffet. Others grumbled that without the sales of t-shirts, candles, toy soldiers, and various pieces of Chamberlainia and Lost Cause mania items, they would lose what one called “the eternal struggle at Gettysburg, between town, gown, park, and developers.” Finally, a local reporter sighed that perhaps he would have to expand his list of sources beyond the index card of names and addresses that had served him so long and so well, entitled “The Usual Suspects.”
Latschar could hardly conceal a smile when he learned of these complaints. “The lesson of Gettysburg was that to win, you had to find good ground, then hold it,” he said. “And that’s just what we’ve done.”
… It is April 1.