The Dog-Eared Archive

A historian's notebook on Civil War books, archival research, and how historical writing gets made.

Julian Harrow

Civil Warriors Blog: Historians on the American Civil War

The Civil Warriors blog brought academic historians together to argue about the American Civil War online: its writers, debates, and archive.

The Civil Warriors blog was a group site where academic historians argued about the American Civil War in public between 2005 and 2012. Mark Grimsley started it in 2005 with graduate students, and Ethan Rafuse and Brooks Simpson joined the conversation. Web Archive records show the page carried the tagline about refighting the war one post at a time from 2007 through 2015. Its entries took up Reconstruction and the craft of publishing, and readers hunting Civil War books still meet its arguments through the historians’ later publications.

Who were the historians behind the Civil Warriors blog?

The Civil Warriors blog was written by working academic historians. Civil War Bookshelf described the March 2006 group blog as the work of Mark Grimsley and Steven Woodworth, with Brooks Simpson also writing. The surviving mirror’s About note, accessed November 16, 2026, names Grimsley of Ohio State University and Ethan Rafuse as its collaborators. The same notice called the site a potential diary of new thinking in Civil War history. Rafuse serves as professor of military history at the Army Command and General Staff College at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, according to the University Press of Kansas author page accessed November 16, 2026. He taught at West Point in 2001–2003, held the Ewing chair there in 2018–2019, and has more than 350 articles and reviews, according to the Civil War Round Table of Kansas City biography accessed November 16, 2026.

How did blog drafts become Civil War books and articles?

Civil Warriors treated blogging as drafting in public, and at least one post became a paid magazine article. Grimsley’s opening post of January 24, 2005, on the blog’s Blogger mirror, says 11 days of blogging produced a 7,000-word series that he revised within hours into an article for North and South magazine. The $600 commission bought him many books, in his words, and the post framed the blog as an intellectual force multiplier. That habit of writing out loud joins other lessons learned from working historians.

Where did the original Civil Warriors site go?

The original Civil Warriors site lived at this WordPress address, and readers now meet it through its Blogger mirror. A September 2006 mirror note describes a server outage, and a January 2012 post describes a malicious-script attack that left Grimsley no time for a decisive fix. He set a redirect to the blog’s former Blogger home and announced that he and Ethan were back in action. The mirror documents each move in a dated post; the stages are summarized below.

Online home How readers reached it What changed
Blogger, first home Direct visit Launch posts appeared here
WordPress edition at this address Direct visit Group blog linked by outside sites
Blogger mirror, second home Redirect from the WordPress address Posting resumed after the outage
The mirror’s About note calls the Blogger site a temporary bivouac during the outage. “Until the problem is solved, we’ll conduct operations from here,” say the editors in the undated About note on the blog’s Blogger mirror. For readers attempting a similar rescue, the tutorials section is the place to look.

What dissenting view did Civil Warriors offer on Reconstruction?

Civil Warriors dissented from the idea that the Civil War ended cleanly in 1865. In a February 2012 interview reposted on the blog, Grimsley told Small Wars Journal editor Mike Few that the federal government’s two goals, restoration of the Union and destruction of slavery, had both been achieved by 1865. Congress then held the former Confederate states in the grasp of war until Black male suffrage and new political terms took hold, in his account. He added that Louisiana alone saw an estimated 2,500 deaths from political violence between 1865 and 1876. The thread reads as public Q&A between scholars.

Civil Warriors 常见问题

Who wrote the Civil Warriors blog?

The Civil Warriors blog was written by academic historians led by Mark Grimsley of Ohio State University and Ethan Rafuse of the Army Command and General Staff College. Brooks Simpson and Steven Woodworth contributed in its early group-blog phase. A March 2006 notice in Civil War Bookshelf named Grimsley and Woodworth as the writers, with Simpson also writing, and tipped the site as a diary of new thinking. Rafuse later held the Ewing chair at West Point in 2018–2019.

What dissenting view did Civil Warriors publish on Reconstruction?

Civil Warriors argued that Reconstruction acted as a Southern insurgency that broke the federal government’s grasp of war and restored conservative home rule. Grimsley gave that answer in a February 2012 interview reposted on the blog, while noting the Union’s two war goals had been met by 1865. He cited an estimated 2,500 deaths from political violence in Louisiana between 1865 and 1876. The post answers readers who ask why the war’s end did not stop the killing.

Where can the Civil Warriors archive be read today?

The surviving Civil Warriors archive sits on the blog’s Blogger mirror, which Grimsley set as the redirect target after malicious script crippled the WordPress edition. A September 2006 mirror note records a server outage, and a January 2012 post announces the redirect and the return of Grimsley and Rafuse. The mirror’s About note frames the Blogger site as a temporary bivouac until the problem is solved. The mirror’s archive lists posts from 2005, 2006, and 2012.

What does ‘Digitizing Sherman’s March’ mean for Civil Warriors readers?

The ‘Digitizing Sherman’s March’ anchor refers to digital-history work on Sherman’s campaign, notably Mapping Memory by historian Anne Sarah Rubin. A November 2014 WYPR report previews the project’s public lecture at the UMBC Dresher Center on December 2, 2014. For Civil Warriors readers the link sits among memory-themed references alongside battle markers and campaign studies. It shows the blog’s interest in how the war is mapped and remembered.

The surviving mirror does not identify which post the lone ‘obituary’ anchor meant, so no single Civil Warriors obituary can be confirmed from the accessible archive. The two German ‘Nachruf’ anchors point to the same address and likewise name no deceased person. These anchors date from the WordPress years, alongside debate and publishing notes. Readers following them should search the mirror’s 2005–2006 posts for memorial entries.

#Civil War Blogs#Civil War History#Military Historians#Publishing Lessons

Related articles

Kings Mountain Battle Books Worth Reading Before You GoKings Mountain battle books worth buying, from Moss rosters to new campaign histories and archive sources. Lessons Learned
Original Civil War Letters: Value, Care and Reading GuideOriginal Civil War letters often sell for $10-$25; battle detail raises value. Learn to read, verify, preserve and trace regiments. Lessons Learned